Witches Brew Sangria (Easy Halloween Cocktail Recipe)

What is Witches Brew Sangria?

Witches Brew Sangria is a Halloween twist on the classic Spanish punch. It is made with red wine, citrus fruit, sparkling water, and a splash of bourbon for extra warmth. What makes this one magical is the dramatic addition of dry ice, which creates a foggy, bubbling cauldron effect.

Want to save this recipe?

I’ll email this recipe to you, so that you can come back to it later!

Email *

Save Recipe

Ingredients & Substitutions

Here is what you need to make this spook-tacular potion. The full ingredient list and instructions are in the recipe card below.

• Red Wine – Choose a medium-bodied red with fruity notes. I like Apothic Dark, but Tempranillo, Garnacha, or Primitivo are also good choices.
• Blood Orange – Adds a dramatic red hue. If you cannot find them, regular oranges work fine.
• Lime – Adds brightness and balances the flavors.
• Sparkling Mineral Water – Topo Chico is my go-to, but club soda or seltzer works too.
• Bourbon (optional) – Adds depth and warmth. You can also try rum, vodka, tequila, or brandy.
• Dry Ice – Creates the smoky, bubbling effect. Handle with care and never touch with bare skin.

How to Make Witches Brew Sangria

Step 1: Mix sangria. In a large container, preferably a cauldron, combine wine, citrus, and sparkling water. I found a really cute ceramic witch’s cauldron to act as my punch bowl. A black iron dutch oven or traditional caldero would also be great options.

Step 2: Add the “poison.” Pour bourbon into test tubes or shot glasses so guests can spike their own glass.

Step 3: Add dry ice. Carefully place a piece of dry ice into the serving vessel right before serving. Wait until it melts before sipping.

Optional Variations

• Kid-friendly version – Use Agua de Jamaica (Hibiscus Tea), Calientito (Warm Pear Cider), or Mexican Hot Chocolate with dry ice for spooky flair.
• Different spirits – Offer a variety of liquors in test tubes, such as brandy, tequila, or vodka, so guests can choose their favorite.
• Other sangrias – Try my Winter White Sangria or Christmas Fruit Sangria.

(Note: These variations have not all been tested. If you try them, let me know how it turned out in the comments below!)

Frequently Asked Questions